The Wild Robot Escapes


The Wild Robot Escapes (hardcover)

by Peter Brown


When I first read The Wild Robot, I had high expectations for it.  I’d heard a lot about it, and there was a lot of talk on Twitter and the reading communities I follow.  I was disappointed.  That’s why it took me awhile to buy it for my classroom, and I almost didn’t buy the sequel, except that a few of my students read it and enjoyed it, so I figured I’d buy it and read it, anyway.  I loved the sequel!

In The Wild Robot Escapes, Roz finds herself refurbished on a farm.  She is the new helper to a widower and his children.  They’re mourning the loss of a wife and mother, and Roz is mourning the loss (or separation) of her son, Brightbill, who is now the leader of his flock of geese.  Roz builds a relationship with the animals on the farm and the two children, and they help her escape by removing her tracking device.  Roz is then free to escape and try to return home to their island, but not before facing danger and an important mystery person in her life.

What I liked about this book was that Roz gained a bigger sense of the world in her role as a mother.  She also learned her purpose, which is to help.  She stands firm in not causing harm to others, while still protecting those she loves.  I think this is a great message for our children, that you can make change and stand up and protect others without resorting to violence or hurting others.

What I didn’t like about this book was that it had me hooked!  It’s usually the first book that is awesome and the second one that is harder to enjoy, but this was engaging and filled with emotion from beginning to end.  If you’re like me and you didn’t care for the first book so much, definitely give the second one a try.  I even missed lunch with friends, because I had to read in my classroom alone.

Book 65 of 40

(Book 31 of 2018)




Bob (ebook)

by Rebecca Stead and Wendy Mass


Bob is an imaginative story about a girl named Olivia (Livy) who goes to Australia to visit her grandmother, and finds a friendly creature named Bob in the closet.  Bob knows Livy, but remembers her differently, having been friends with her 6 years prior when Livy was 5 years old.  Last they saw each other, Livy told Bob to wait in the closet, but never returned for her.  Now, Livy has to get to k now Bob all over again, and finds herself in the middle of mystery she can’t quite wrap her head around since she forgets Bob when she leaves the farm.

What I liked about this book was that I didn’t predict it.  Often with stories for younger readers or middle graders, I predict how the story will end, and I don’t enjoy it quite as much since it doesn’t challenge me.  This is a shorter story, but entertaining beginning to end.  I was interested in Bob’s origin and circumstances, why Livy couldn’t remember him, and how he related to the drought that was causing everyone to lose their farms.  I did not predict the ending.  It is an enjoyable story with mystery, humor, and imagination.  I found myself giggling at Bob’s antics and the witty inner thoughts of Bob and Livy.

What I didn’t like about this book was that it’s not out yet for me to share with my students.  It’s one that I wanted to take to class and put into the hands of someone else immediately, but I’ll have to wait another few weeks.  I know it might take some selling since my group this year gravitates towards realistic and historical fiction, but it is one they will enjoy once they give it a chance.

Book 64 of 40

(Book 30 of 2018)

Mighty Jack and the Goblin King


Mighty Jack and the Goblin King (paperback)

by Ben Hatke


I really enjoyed Mighty Jack, but it left me hanging.  Mighty Jack and the Goblin King is the second installation, and as far as I know, Hatke only has or plans to write these two.  Jack and Lilley have gone into the garden to look for Jack’s sister, who was captured by a giant.  When they get there, they discover a world with Goblins (who turn out to be good), Giants (who are bad), and these weird rat things that chew through the vines and pipes.  Jack and Lilley are separated, but both face danger in search of Jack’s sister.  They make allies and fight the bad guys, and have a final challenge at the end that will appeal to all of my female students.  It doesn’t leave us hanging, but segues into another of Hatke’s series by introducing us to some of his other characters.

What I liked about this book was the girl power.  Lilley took charge and was given an important job where she faced tough choices, but came out on top.  Jack had to rely on Lilley’s quick thinking a few times, which is a nice change up from “the boy saves the girl.”  However, there was the porch scene that was a nice surprise.

What I didn’t like about this book was the way is was crammed in.  I felt like there was potential for other parts to be developed and explained, but overall, Hatke did a great job of writing an engaging graphic novel for my sixth grade readers.  And their teacher.

Book 55 of 40

(Book 21 of 2018)

Hour of the Bees


Hour of the Bees (hardcover)

by Lindsay Eager

AR Level 4.5, 9 points


Hour of the Bees was talked about last year, and it was one I never got to before the ALA awards (it didn’t win).  It was really good!  I don’t know what took me so long!  Carol isn’t looking forward to her summer on her grandpa’s sheep ranch.  He has Alzheimer’s, and her father’s plan is to sell the ranch and get him moved into a retirement home.  Carol’s job is to help them get the house packed up, while watching her little brother, avoiding her older sister, and missing out on her friends’ exciting summer before starting middle school.  She is annoyed by the bees that keep appearing around her head, despite the intense heat and drought.  Carol is also in charge of watching her grandpa Serge, but she finds herself immersed in his stories about Sergio and Rosa and a magical tree.  What starts out as a story about an annoyed tween becomes a fantastic story that will have you glued to your book.  I read most of it in one day.

What I liked about this book was the way it sucked me into the story of Sergio and Rosa and the magical tree.  I knew where the story was likely going, but I was really hoping it wasn’t a strange alternate reality (think of Don Juan DeMarco with Johnny Depp).  This book did not disappoint.  I was happy with where it was going and how it ended, and I may have even shed a tear at the end.

What I didn’t like about this book was the character of Alta.  She bugged me, and I didn’t like the way she was a super B and then became nice in the end.

Book 7 of summer 2017!

Maybe A Fox


Maybe A Fox (paperback)

by Kathi Appelt

AR Level 4.9, 5 points


Maybe A Fox is one I’d read about on Twitter, but hadn’t put much thought  into buying it, because I didn’t really know what it was about, so it sat on my Amazon shopping list.  Then I saw it was in Scholastic, bought it, and waited until a student read it.  FYI: When a sixth grade boy brings it to you with tears in his eyes and tells you you should read it, you stop what you’re doing and pick it up.  That’s what I did, and I’m glad!  Also a warning, though- it is not a “feel good” book.  It is sad.  You will likely cry, or at least get teary or a little depressed after.

I’m partially torn, because it was too real for me.  Two sisters, very close in age (like my two daughters) lost their mother and are connected at the hip.  They fight with each other, share friends, and love each other more than anyone.  Like my two daughters.  Then one of the sisters goes missing at the exact moment a litter of foxes is born, and that’s where the fantasy comes in… that’s not like my two daughters, but the thought of one of them dying while the other one has to go on… too much!  I was ready to stop right there!  So the little fox feels drawn to the remaining sister, and helps her to find closure, since  no body was ever found.  At the same time, a young man is dealing with the death of his best friend in Afghanistan, and a wild cat is spotted.  It sounds like a lot to take in, and it is, but this story was written beautifully and all of the coincidences make sense in the end.  When you’re done, you will close the book, and sit in contemplation, soaking it all in.

What I liked about the book was the beauty of the relationships.  Maybe it was the sister-sister connection, the best friends, the fox kits, the mother to her daughter or the father to his daughters- they were all lovely and well-developed, I felt.  I felt the pain of the loss, and I didn’t lose any of them myself.

What I didn’t like about this book was the end.  I won’t spoil it, but there was one last jab in my heart that some felt was unnecessary.  I didn’t see it as unnecessary, but it hurt just the same.  I won’t give spoilers, but when you think it’s over, just wait for one more thing to happen.  This isn’t a funny book, and it isn’t heartwarming, but it will leave you feeling like it came full circle.

Book 46 of 40 (40 Book Challenge)

Mr. and Mrs. Bunny – Detectives Extraordinaire!


Mr. and Mrs. Bunny – Detectives Extraordinaire!

by Polly Horvath

AR Level 4.8, 6 points

This is the story of a girl named Madeline and the kidnapping of her hippie parents, Flo and Mildred.  Madeline is a responsible, intelligent young girl who wants to be normal, but her hippie parents live in a commune and do not respect modern day society and their focus on education and Prince Charles.  Madeline comes home to find her parents had been kidnapped by some wicked foxes, who wanted the address to her Uncle Runyon’s house, hoping he could translate a rabbit recipe for their new factory that will make rabbit by-products.  Madeline enlists the help of some rabbit friends, and they go one an adventure to rescue her parents and get her to the school in time to meet Prince Charles at her graduation ceremony.

What I liked about this book was that it had a lot of smart-alecky jokes.  As you know, I love smart dialogue.  Mr. and Mrs. Bunny are constantly bickering, which is humorous, and they have quick and snarky comebacks for each other, without being inappropriate.  Their marriage is actually quite realistic!  Though they argue, they have a deep love for each other, and a love for Madeline as their “pet” or adopted daughter.  It is a funny, light-hearted, whimsical story, and it is no wonder it is a Parents’ Choice Award-winning book.

What I didn’t like about this book was that it hold my attention.  It just couldn’t get through it.  Maybe if I’d been reading it to my children, I could have stayed engaged, but for some reason, it lost my attention half way through.  I had to just buckle down and finish the second half this afternoon.  I can see it as an animated film someday, and that would be lovely.

Book 3 of 40 (year 2)

Miss Peregrine’s Home For Peculiar Children


Miss Peregrine’s Home For Peculiar Children (paperback)

by Ransom Riggs

AR Level 5.7, 13 points

I’d heard about this book here and there.  One of my students ordered it in a book order and the title sounded interesting, but it was long before I even considered my reading challenge.  (I was all “read, read, read!” but I never actually picked up a book myself- what a hypocrite.)  When I heard that my love, Lemony Snicket, was interviewed by Ransom Riggs at the Festival of Books last weekend, I googled Riggs to find out who he was and saw he authored this book.  If he’s good enough to share a stage or a platform or whatever with Snicket, he must be worth reading.  Not to mention being on the New York Times Best Sellers List, but you know, that’s secondary. 

What I didn’t know about this book was the fact that it is dark- Harry Potter dark.  There are parts that might not be appropriate for younger readers, and I have to admit that my heart raced a few times after some of the creepier parts.  I came to school and scolded my student who let me borrow the book for not warning me that I’d get creeped out!  She, of course, just laughed at me and told me it didn’t bother her.  Once you get past the initial shock, though, it’s not so bad.

The story starts out with a boy named Jacob and a family tragedy.  Have you ever lost someone in your family, and then realized there were so many questions you wanted to ask that person, but never got a chance?  My grandma died when I was in college, and while I have been told I had a lot in common with her, there are so many things I wish I’d had the chance to talk to her about.  So anyway, Jacob loses his grandfather and then discovers this past life he had, these secrets he’d kept (but not really), and explanations for why his grandfather was so cuckoo.  He travels to a Welsh island with a long history that helps Jacob understand the stories his grandfather told, and meets some new friends (and enemies) while he’s there.  I can’t tell too much about what happens without giving the story away, because anything I’d say would be too much information!  There are plot twists and chapter cliffhangers that I don’t want to spoil for you.

I can’t talk about this book without mentioning the pictures.  Riggs collects old photographs and built back stories and plot twists around the photographs.  They really add to the story and the characters.  However, I sometimes had to look ahead to see if there was a bizarre picture, especially if I was reading at night.  I didn’t want to dream about the images or wonder if a white-eyed wight was waiting for me in the hallway.

What I liked about this book was…nearly everything!  I’ve said before that I love books with well-developed characters, and this book has many well-developed characters that you grow to love throughout the book.  The main character is the typical underdog you can relate to- a teenager, misunderstood by his peers, highly intelligent, with a kind heart, and a do-gooder attitude.  You just like the protaganists of the story, and hate the antagonists.  That’s what you’re supposed to do, right?

What I didn’t like was that it was a little Harry Potter-ish.  Don’t get me wrong- I enjoyed Harry Potter.  I read all of the books and saw all of the movies the weekend they came out in the theater.  I started to sense a pattern, and it became a little predictable.  And I didn’t expect the story NOT to end when I finished the book.  So, I guess that means I’ll be starting Hollow City tomorrow!

Thank you to Daniela for lending me both books.  I love when a student can recommend a book for her teacher!

Book 3 of 52